Skip to main content

Notes from November 5th Language Design Meeting

Dart engineer Bob Nystrom has posted the notes from the November 5th language design meeting. He writes:

Here's my notes from last week's meeting. There's no meeting this week, so this will have to tide you over. :)

NoSuchMethod and ()

Lars brought up bug 6428.

In Dart, if you call foo(), you get a noSuchMethod error for method "foo". If you call (foo)(), you get noSuchMethod error for getter "foo". This is how the language is specified and it's the behavior the designers expected, but dart2js doesn't currently do it correctly, and the behavior may be unintuitive.

Gilad says he'll look at the bug.

Forwarding

Lars: If you want to forward something with optional params. Right now you cannot.
Gilad: I want to look at it some more. I'd like to reuse mechanism.
Bob: We realized this in Seattle shortly after the new signature stuff came out. After some discussion, our guideline is just "never use that question mark operator thing" since it breaks forwards.
Lars: The problem is not the question mark operator. Cannot cleanly do pass-along in noSuchMethod either.
Gilad: Question operator was part of solution but doesn't work in all cases.

There's more context on this here: http://code.google.com/p/dart/issues/detail?id=6496.

Configuration-specific code

Lars: We handle this in the core libraries using patch but we don't definitely don't want to expose that to the world. We need a solution. Proposals are welcome, but would really like something that's extremely simple.

"abstract" modifier

Gilad: It's gone, right?
Bob: Is it optional or gone?
Lars: We originally planned to make it optional but we discussed it some more. If you make it optional, you get stylistic wobble. Some people will use it and some won't. If it's optional, we couldn't find good places where it made sense to put it in.
Lars: So decision as of today is that abstract is not allowed for members.

Call operator and call() method on SendPort

In the spec, when you do foo(), if foo is an object with a call() method, it desugars to invoking that. Unrelated, SendPort has a method named call().

Gilad: Don't want to be able to call on a SendPort using just parentheses. Should we renamed the method, or consider changing the language to have an actual operator ()?  There's a lot of moving parts so not sure if we want to do this.
Lars: The operator would be more symmetric with how its called. Is this is a pressing issue?
Gilad: Presumably it will get implemented soon and people may start using the current semantics.
Lars: Can you file a bug to track it?

Wrong number of type arguments

Gilad: We intended to change it from an error to a warning.
Lars: What are the semantics?
Gilad: If it has the wrong number of type arguments, it will throw at the constructor.

Shadowing setters

Lars: Have an open issue about pairwise shadowing of fields.

Here's an example. Start with this:

    class Foo {
      var bar;

      method() {
        var bar = 1;
        bar = 2; // assign to local
      }
    }

Now change it to:

    class Foo {
      var bar;

      method() {
        final bar = 1; // var -> final
        bar = 2; // call setter!
      }
    }

We should look at some sort of pairwise shadowing. Otherwise it's too surprising.

We all agree this should be solved. We can work on this when we are in person.

Cheers!

As always, we invite you to join our Dart mailing list, ask questions on Stack Overflow, or file feature requests on dartbug.com.

Popular posts from this blog

AngularDart 4

AngularDart v4 is now available. We've been busy since the release angular2 v3.1.0 in May. Not only did we "drop the 2", but we also improved the compiler and tightened up the framework to give you smaller code, we updated the package structure to improve usability, and we added several new features. Check out the updated documentation to get started.
Just angular Upgrading to v4 will require more than updating your version constraint. The package has changed names (back) to angular – dropping the 2. You'll need to update your pubspec.yaml and the corresponding imports in your code. In most instances, find-and-replace should do the trick. Going forward, the package will be called package:angular. We'll just update the version number.
Smaller code The updated compiler in 4.0 allows type-based optimizations that not only improve runtime performance but generate better code because we are able to strongly type templates. A big result of the update is that many ap…

Const, Static, Final, Oh my!

Posted by Seth Ladd

(This is an "oldie but a goodie" misc@dartlang.org post originally written by Bob Nystrom. It is being posted here as the explanations still ring true.)

Bob writes:


"static", "final", and "const" mean entirely distinct things in Dart:

"static" means a member is available on the class itself instead of on instances of the class. That's all it means, and it isn't used for anything else. static modifies *members*.

"final" means single-assignment: a final variable or field *must* have an initializer. Once assigned a value, a final variable's value cannot be changed. final modifies *variables*.

"const" has a meaning that's a bit more complex and subtle in Dart. const modifies *values*. You can use it when creating collections, like const [1, 2, 3], and when constructing objects (instead of new) like const Point(2, 3). Here, const means that the object's entire deep state can be determ…

The new AdWords UI uses Dart — we asked why

Google just announced a re-designed AdWords experience. In case you’re not familiar with AdWords: businesses use it to advertise on google.com and partner websites. Advertising makes up majority of Google’s revenue, so when Google decides to completely redo the customer-facing front end to it, it’s a big deal. The Dart team is proud to say that this new front end is built with Dart and Angular 2. Whenever you asked us whether Google is ‘even using Dart for anything,’ this is what we had in mind but couldn’t say aloud. Until now. We asked Joshy Joseph, the primary technical lead on the project, some questions. Joshy is focusing on things like infrastructure, application latency and development velocity, so he’s the right person to ask about Dart.Q: What exactly did we launch on Monday?It’s a complete redesign of the AdWords customer experience that is rolling out slowly as a test to a small initial set of advertisers. The most noticeable thing is probably the Material Design look and f…